Teach Sleep Repeat
Teach Sleep Repeat cover art

Episodes Episode 197

Big debates

Is Setting In Maths Actually A Good Thing?

Episode 197, 6 May 2026, 72 min

In this episode

For about twenty-five years, the dominant message in teacher training has been clear. The research says mixed attainment is better. Setting damages confidence, harms low attainers, and widens the gap. Then in April 2026, the EEF published a study that complicates all of that.

Nine thousand pupils, 97 schools, two years of data. The finding: pupils in mixed attainment classes made roughly one month less progress in maths than pupils in sets. High prior attainers made two months less progress. And the team that produced this result is the same team that gave us most of the evidence against setting in the first place.

Dylan and Hayden get into what the study actually found and what it did not find, what they were both taught during training and whether they still believe it, and the honest classroom experience that the academic literature tends not to capture.

They also make the strongest possible case for both sides before landing somewhere honest. The mixed attainment argument does not collapse because of one study. The setting argument is not vindicated either. But the conversation has shifted and anyone working in secondary maths right now deserves to know how and why.

Sharp, properly researched, and the kind of debate that should be happening in every staffroom in the country.

🎧 New episodes every week. Leave us a review if you enjoy the show!

💬 Join our completely free WhatsApp community and connect with teachers from across the UK: https://chat.whatsapp.com/HB7n1PNGdGL5STACssEH1s

Topics

More like this

More of the big debates.

  1. 198

    Big debates

    Should Teachers Model Healthy Eating? Plus Quickest ECT Quits, Ethical Issues & Zombie Outbreaks

    11 May 2026, 38 min

    A teacher writes in asking if it is genuinely acceptable to eat biscuits and drink sugary drinks in front of children.

    Listen
  2. 195

    Big debates

    Will The Smartphone Ban In Schools Actually Change Anything?

    29 April 2026, 61 min

    England just made the school phone ban statutory. From this autumn, banning phones during the school day is not just guidance schools can choose to follow.

    Listen
  3. 193

    Big debates

    Does It Matter What Kids Eat At School?

    22 April 2026, 61 min

    The government just announced the biggest shake-up of school food standards in over a decade. Ice cream is gone.

    Listen
Listen Newsletter